Hands-on test · October 2026

We Redesigned the Same PowerPoint with 4 AI Tools

One plain 8-slide company deck, run through BetterPPT, Gamma, Wonderslide and Plus AI. Here are the real exports side by side — what each tool kept, what it changed or added, and what it costs.

By the BetterPPT team. We make BetterPPT, so treat this as a vendor test — but every image below is an unedited export, and we list each tool's settings so you can repeat it.

Short answer

  • Most designed result: BetterPPT — every slide is designed as a whole picture, so it can build creative layouts: a timeline drawn from a scene that fits the topic, a creative cover and contents page, your photos re-composed and new imagery added, from real scenes to 3D and miniature graphics. The text and the picture are drawn together, so a title sits straight in a calm area of the scene with no color block behind it. Your first slides (up to six) are ready in about 10 minutes and the rest of a 30-slide deck in about 10 more, where a designer takes days. One-time price with no subscription: $39 for up to 30 slides, and new users currently pay a limited-time $9.75. You edit the returned .pptx in PowerPoint.
  • Fastest, with an editor in the browser: Gamma — about 5–6 minutes, a generated cover image, consulting-style headlines, and every word editable in its built-in editor. It also rewrites headlines and adds its own summary lines, so check the text. In our testing it generates the picture and puts the text on a color block over it, as separate layers.
  • Cheapest per deck: Wonderslide — $4.99 and a few minutes, with bold AI illustrations. In its “Improve and refine” mode it dropped most of the numbers on our data-heavy slides.
  • Most conservative: Plus AI — keeps the text as written and exports a native PowerPoint, but the slides stay close to a standard template.

How we tested

The source deck is an 8-slide corporate introduction for a sample company: title slide, contents, about us, technology, manufacturing, products, case studies and roadmap. Most slides are plain bullet points; 7 photos appear on 3 slides. On October 18, 2026 we uploaded the same .pptx to each tool and used its guided flow:

The source deck, all export images and the scoring data are on GitHub so you can rerun the test: github.com/michaelkong1018/betterppt-redesign-benchmark

BetterPPT
Uploaded the .pptx, answered the setup questions, downloaded the HD image version.
Gamma
Imported the .pptx into Gamma's redesign agent, answered its setup form and accepted its suggested direction; exported the slides.
Wonderslide
Answered its two questions with “Improve and refine (Recommended)” and “Modern Tech”; downloaded the free PDF (watermarked). We later re-ran it with “Preserve exact structure”.
Plus AI
Asked it to “redesign and make it look better and professional” in the Plus AI editor (Basic plan); exported the PPTX.

Results at a glance

BetterPPTGammaWonderslidePlus AI
Works on your existing deckYes — upload a .pptxYes — import a .pptxYes — PPTX, PDF, DOCX and moreYes — import into its editor
Layout approachEach slide designed individuallyTemplate-based, consulting-style blocksStyle preset, card layoutsTemplate-style layouts, cards
New imageryYes, on most slidesYes — generated cover imageYes, on some slidesNone added in our test
Your original photosRe-composed, used full-bleedPlaced as-isPlaced as-is in cardsPlaced as-is
Text on data-heavy slidesFigures kept and enlargedFigures kept; headlines rewritten, summary lines addedMostly dropped in “Improve” mode; kept in “Preserve” modeKept as written
EditingDownload the .pptx and edit in PowerPointEvery element editable in its built-in editorBuilt-in editorBuilt-in editor
File you getEditable .pptx + HD imagesGamma deck; PPTX / PDF exportFree: watermarked PDF. Paid: editable PPTX + PDFNative .pptx
See results before paying in fullUp to 6 pages after a $9.90 deposit (half the pages for decks of 12 or fewer)Free plan with one-time creditsWhole deck, watermarked, freeWe tested on a paid plan
TimeAbout 15–20 min for 30 slidesAbout 5–6 minAbout 5–6 minNot timed
Price$39 up to 30 slides, $59 for 31–50, one-timeFree plan; paid plans roughly $8–20 per seat/mo$4.99 per deck; subscriptions $12.99–24.99/moSubscriptions from $15/user/mo (Pro $25)
How the slides look (our reading of the three slides above)Full-bleed scenes and photo backdrops, large numbers over the pictures; the manufacturing panels are the photographsCream panel and flat cream backgrounds, stat columns, a “So what” bar, photos in boxesPlain dark background, outlined cards, centred text; one generated illustrationFlat light backgrounds, white text cards, small photos under the text

Prices as shown on each product's checkout or pricing page on October 18, 2026. Gamma's pricing page blocked our checker, so its range comes from third-party listings — check gamma.app/pricing.

Slide by slide

Title slide

The original is four lines of text on white. No image.

Original
Original
BetterPPT — full-bleed factory scene, company name as the headline
BetterPPT — full-bleed factory scene, company name as the headline
Gamma — generated factory image with a text block; the tagline became the headline and the company name moved to a small label
Gamma — generated factory image with a text block; the tagline became the headline and the company name moved to a small label
Wonderslide — dark solid background, centered text
Wonderslide — dark solid background, centered text
Plus AI — light panel plus a navy block with the year
Plus AI — light panel plus a navy block with the year

Technology & R&D (a data-heavy slide)

Five bullets packed with figures — 11% of revenue, 1,200+ engineers, 800+ patents, 6 R&D centers, 60% faster cycles, 34% fewer defects — plus one lab photo.

Original
Original
BetterPPT — photo used as the backdrop, three key numbers enlarged; title rewritten as a takeaway
BetterPPT — photo used as the backdrop, three key numbers enlarged; title rewritten as a takeaway
Gamma — takeaway headline, two big stats, a “So what” bar; the photo label “Shanghai Lab 02” isn't in the original
Gamma — takeaway headline, two big stats, a “So what” bar; the photo label “Shanghai Lab 02” isn't in the original
Wonderslide (“Improve and refine”) — two cards and two images; most figures removed
Wonderslide (“Improve and refine”) — two cards and two images; most figures removed
Plus AI — white card, original photo, navy stat bar; text as written
Plus AI — white card, original photo, navy stat bar; text as written

Manufacturing system

Five bullets and two photos. This is Wonderslide's strongest slide in our test.

BetterPPT — the two photos become two large panels with the headline numbers on top
BetterPPT — the two photos become two large panels with the headline numbers on top
Gamma — takeaway headline, four stats under two small photos
Gamma — takeaway headline, four stats under two small photos
Wonderslide — a generated isometric factory with all five points as callouts
Wonderslide — a generated isometric factory with all five points as callouts
Plus AI — two text cards with the photos small underneath
Plus AI — two text cards with the photos small underneath

What each tool kept on the data-heavy slide

We checked every fact on the Technology & R&D slide against the original.

Fact in the originalBetterPPTGammaWonderslide (Improve)Plus AI
R&D spend = 11% of revenueKeptKeptDroppedKept
10%–14% industry benchmarkFolded into the title, number not shownKeptDroppedKept
1,200+ R&D engineersKeptKeptDroppedKept
800+ granted patentsKeptKeptDroppedKept
6 global R&D centersKeptDroppedDroppedKept
Digital twin: R&D cycles up to 60% shorterKeptKeptKeptKept
AI inspection: 34% fewer defectsKeptKeptDroppedKept
Core technology listKeptKeptKeptKept
Joint innovation with universities and labsKeptKeptKeptKept

Two different risks showed up. Wonderslide's “Improve and refine” mode removed figures — the About Us slide also lost the 18,000+ employees and USD 4.2B revenue — but with “Preserve exact structure” the numbers stayed. Gamma kept almost every figure but added text of its own: a “So what” line on each slide and a photo label (“Global R&D Center · Shanghai Lab 02”) that isn't in the source. BetterPPT offers three modes at setup — keep every word, allow light editing, or allow restructuring; whichever tool you use, re-read the slides before you present. We did not run BetterPPT's keep-every-word mode on this deck. In a separate real job on a clinical teaching deck, run in that mode, we compared six slides with the original: no wording changed, except that two questions became two bullets, and the title slide gained a small mark and a repeated subtitle that weren't in the original.

Which one should you use?

Gamma

Best if you want a strong result fast and plan to keep editing in the browser. The built-in editor is the best of the four. Check every headline and summary line it writes.

BetterPPT

Best for decks that matter — a client pitch, an investor meeting, a board update — where the slides need to look designed rather than templated and your photos need work. Every slide is analysed and designed individually as a whole picture, which opens up creative layouts: timelines built from a scene that fits the topic, creative covers and contents pages, real scenes or 3D and miniature graphics. The first slides (up to six) are ready in about 10 minutes and the rest of a 30-slide deck in about 10 more, minutes rather than a designer's days; one-time price, no subscription, and new users currently pay a limited-time $9.75. You edit the returned .pptx in PowerPoint.

Wonderslide

Best if budget matters most: $4.99 and a few minutes for a bold, consistent look, and you can see the whole deck (watermarked) before paying. Choose “Preserve exact structure” if your figures must stay.

Plus AI

Best if you want to stay close to the original and keep working in PowerPoint or Google Slides. In this test it was the safest for wording, but the visual change is modest.

More on how BetterPPT and Gamma differ: BetterPPT vs Gamma →

Questions

Which AI tool redesigns an existing PowerPoint without changing the content?

In our test, Plus AI kept the wording as written and BetterPPT kept every figure (and lets you choose “use my text exactly as written”). Gamma kept nearly all figures but rewrote headlines and added its own summary lines. Wonderslide kept the numbers only in its “Preserve exact structure” mode. We didn't run BetterPPT's keep-every-word mode on this deck; in a separate keep-every-word job on a clinical teaching deck, none of the wording changed across the six slides we compared.

Which tools give you an editable PowerPoint file?

BetterPPT includes an editable .pptx with real text boxes. Plus AI exports a native .pptx and Gamma offers PPTX export. Wonderslide's free download is a watermarked PDF; editable PPTX comes with its paid options. Gamma, Wonderslide and Plus AI also let you edit inside their own editors; BetterPPT does not.

What's the cheapest way to redesign one deck?

Wonderslide at $4.99 per deck, or Gamma's free plan if its one-time credits cover your deck. Plus AI is a monthly subscription from $15. BetterPPT is $39 per deck (up to 30 slides) — priced against hiring a designer rather than against other AI tools.

Related

Try it on your own deck